Wazua
»
Club SK
»
Politics
»
Installed Grid Capacity Politrics!!!!!!!!!!!!
Rank: Elder Joined: 2/26/2012 Posts: 15,980
|
limanika wrote:murchr wrote:limanika wrote:kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:@imp, Argentina experiences winter, and peak demand for household/user determines the load and ultimately the required generation capacity. @ Maji the % was 15% last time I checked, but even then, whereas over 50% in Argentina require electricity to heat their houses mainly, over 50% in kenya just need electricity for lighting at night, something we could do with solar. I don't think we need 5000mw right now unless for export urongo mbloo, load shedding saa yote, diesel generators, we need power!!!! if 15% kenyans have access to power today with 1900MW, how much will it take to have 100% coverage? you still think 5000mw is excess? come on the 1900MW is not spread uniformly across the 15%, some facilities consumer over 1mw, while some rural home would only need to light 2 or 3 bulbs for 3-4 hours in the evening. Did you know that even the 15% do not have capacity to fully consume the 1900mw hence we'll be exporting to Rwanda? Plus did you know most Kengen power plants are 'throttled' to produce less than 50% of installed capacity in small hours every Fay coz there's nodemand? What we need is to add capacity in tandem with growth, not to generate 5000mw tomorrow As more jobs and opportunities move to the counties i expect more rural homes to light up those 2 or 3 bulbs and if Kenya attracts more manufacturing plants/companies, that 5000MW will be a drop in the ocean. I have a quick question, why would Kenya import power from Uganda and Ethiopia if there's "No demand"? And isn't demand created? Lets think about the future If at best we would project our economic growth rate to be 5-10% over the next 10 years, would we really need to increase power capacity to 250% suddenly by tomorrow? What we need is strike a proper balance, for instance increase by 50-100MW every year if that’s what our growth demands. Then as we do this, we could focus on creating industries, reduce cost of business, improve security, etc so that we can attract more investors and thereby create the actual demand. If growth rate increases down the line, we increase our investment in power to match. If we were to borrow money and build plants to give us 5000MW which we don’t have capacity to consume in the next 20 years, and can’t export in perpetuity since most of the EAC countries in the region are focussing on power and doing the same thing, how are we going to repay the loans? AND..For world bank to fund current EAC power projects, we have to justify where the demand will come from…that’s partly why there are all these projects to interconnect grids between the various countries….otherwise even world bank would not agree to fund What makes you think that? Fish go bad in Kisumu, Msa and elsewhere due to lack of enough power to refrigerate. Mangoes rot on trees because Ukambani and Msa lacks a plant to process the fruit into something like Juice etc..Maize in farms is infected with alfatoxin mainly because we lack a plant to dry it. For a City, Nairobi is too dark. Heck, we need the power to warm our homes/offices in July and cool them when its too hot. A week doesn't go by without a blackout yet we have electricity in excess? Really? A avg steel plant consumes about 7.8MW how many are there in Kenya, how many are prospecting? "There are only two emotions in the market, hope & fear. The problem is you hope when you should fear & fear when you should hope: - Jesse Livermore .
|
|
|
Rank: Veteran Joined: 9/21/2011 Posts: 2,032
|
kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:murchr wrote:limanika wrote:kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:@imp, Argentina experiences winter, and peak demand for household/user determines the load and ultimately the required generation capacity. @ Maji the % was 15% last time I checked, but even then, whereas over 50% in Argentina require electricity to heat their houses mainly, over 50% in kenya just need electricity for lighting at night, something we could do with solar. I don't think we need 5000mw right now unless for export urongo mbloo, load shedding saa yote, diesel generators, we need power!!!! if 15% kenyans have access to power today with 1900MW, how much will it take to have 100% coverage? you still think 5000mw is excess? come on the 1900MW is not spread uniformly across the 15%, some facilities consumer over 1mw, while some rural home would only need to light 2 or 3 bulbs for 3-4 hours in the evening. Did you know that even the 15% do not have capacity to fully consume the 1900mw hence we'll be exporting to Rwanda? Plus did you know most Kengen power plants are 'throttled' to produce less than 50% of installed capacity in small hours every Fay coz there's nodemand? What we need is to add capacity in tandem with growth, not to generate 5000mw tomorrow As more jobs and opportunities move to the counties i expect more rural homes to light up those 2 or 3 bulbs and if Kenya attracts more manufacturing plants/companies, that 5000MW will be a drop in the ocean. I have a quick question, why would Kenya import power from Uganda and Ethiopia if there's "No demand"? And isn't demand created? Lets think about the future If at best we would project our economic growth rate to be 5-10% over the next 10 years, would we really need to increase power capacity to 250% suddenly by tomorrow? What we need is strike a proper balance, for instance increase by 50-100MW every year if that’s what our growth demands. Then as we do this, we could focus on creating industries, reduce cost of business, improve security, etc so that we can attract more investors and thereby create the actual demand. If growth rate increases down the line, we increase our investment in power to match. If we were to borrow money and build plants to give us 5000MW which we don’t have capacity to consume in the next 20 years, and can’t export in perpetuity since most of the EAC countries in the region are focussing on power and doing the same thing, how are we going to repay the loans? AND..For world bank to fund current EAC power projects, we have to justify where the demand will come from…that’s partly why there are all these projects to interconnect grids between the various countries….otherwise even world bank would not agree to fund Please educate me on how much of the current power we consume is generated from diesel powered generators which I figure are more expensive than hydro or geothermal. Even if you were right, where is the harm in exporting to Rwanda and Uganda? I cringe to think that someone in 2014 AD thinks 5000MW is excess for a country in darkness Combined generating capcity (and thus demand) for UG and Rwanda is about 700MW.If you add TZ, the total for the 3countries is sub 2000MW. So with our 5000MW, we would be able to supply the entire demand in EA (most countries only need import about 10% however) and have 1000MW excess. Is macroeconomics becoming rocket science?
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 12/17/2009 Posts: 3,583 Location: Kenya
|
we are talking increased generation and yet only around 30% of kenyans have access to electricity, compared to around 85% with access to a mobile phone. its funny we are so awed by mega projects and fancy economic figures and yet at the same time the government charges the poorest of the souls money to install electricity poles and transformers.
|
|
|
Rank: Member Joined: 7/9/2011 Posts: 730 Location: Nairobi
|
limanika wrote:kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:murchr wrote:limanika wrote:kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:@imp, Argentina experiences winter, and peak demand for household/user determines the load and ultimately the required generation capacity. @ Maji the % was 15% last time I checked, but even then, whereas over 50% in Argentina require electricity to heat their houses mainly, over 50% in kenya just need electricity for lighting at night, something we could do with solar. I don't think we need 5000mw right now unless for export urongo mbloo, load shedding saa yote, diesel generators, we need power!!!! if 15% kenyans have access to power today with 1900MW, how much will it take to have 100% coverage? you still think 5000mw is excess? come on the 1900MW is not spread uniformly across the 15%, some facilities consumer over 1mw, while some rural home would only need to light 2 or 3 bulbs for 3-4 hours in the evening. Did you know that even the 15% do not have capacity to fully consume the 1900mw hence we'll be exporting to Rwanda? Plus did you know most Kengen power plants are 'throttled' to produce less than 50% of installed capacity in small hours every Fay coz there's nodemand? What we need is to add capacity in tandem with growth, not to generate 5000mw tomorrow As more jobs and opportunities move to the counties i expect more rural homes to light up those 2 or 3 bulbs and if Kenya attracts more manufacturing plants/companies, that 5000MW will be a drop in the ocean. I have a quick question, why would Kenya import power from Uganda and Ethiopia if there's "No demand"? And isn't demand created? Lets think about the future If at best we would project our economic growth rate to be 5-10% over the next 10 years, would we really need to increase power capacity to 250% suddenly by tomorrow? What we need is strike a proper balance, for instance increase by 50-100MW every year if that’s what our growth demands. Then as we do this, we could focus on creating industries, reduce cost of business, improve security, etc so that we can attract more investors and thereby create the actual demand. If growth rate increases down the line, we increase our investment in power to match. If we were to borrow money and build plants to give us 5000MW which we don’t have capacity to consume in the next 20 years, and can’t export in perpetuity since most of the EAC countries in the region are focussing on power and doing the same thing, how are we going to repay the loans? AND..For world bank to fund current EAC power projects, we have to justify where the demand will come from…that’s partly why there are all these projects to interconnect grids between the various countries….otherwise even world bank would not agree to fund Please educate me on how much of the current power we consume is generated from diesel powered generators which I figure are more expensive than hydro or geothermal. Even if you were right, where is the harm in exporting to Rwanda and Uganda? I cringe to think that someone in 2014 AD thinks 5000MW is excess for a country in darkness Combined generating capcity (and thus demand) for UG and Rwanda is about 700MW.If you add TZ, the total for the 3countries is sub 2000MW. So with our 5000MW, we would be able to supply the entire demand in EA (most countries only need import about 10% however) and have 1000MW excess. Is macroeconomics becoming rocket science? so your conclusion is we should sit on our hands now? our goals are best achieved indirectly
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 2/26/2012 Posts: 15,980
|
nakujua wrote:we are talking increased generation and yet only around 30% of kenyans have access to electricity, compared to around 85% with access to a mobile phone. its funny we are so awed by mega projects and fancy economic figures and yet at the same time the government charges the poorest of the souls money to install electricity poles and transformers.
What are you saying? "There are only two emotions in the market, hope & fear. The problem is you hope when you should fear & fear when you should hope: - Jesse Livermore .
|
|
|
Rank: Veteran Joined: 9/21/2011 Posts: 2,032
|
kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:murchr wrote:limanika wrote:kiterunner wrote:limanika wrote:@imp, Argentina experiences winter, and peak demand for household/user determines the load and ultimately the required generation capacity. @ Maji the % was 15% last time I checked, but even then, whereas over 50% in Argentina require electricity to heat their houses mainly, over 50% in kenya just need electricity for lighting at night, something we could do with solar. I don't think we need 5000mw right now unless for export urongo mbloo, load shedding saa yote, diesel generators, we need power!!!! if 15% kenyans have access to power today with 1900MW, how much will it take to have 100% coverage? you still think 5000mw is excess? come on the 1900MW is not spread uniformly across the 15%, some facilities consumer over 1mw, while some rural home would only need to light 2 or 3 bulbs for 3-4 hours in the evening. Did you know that even the 15% do not have capacity to fully consume the 1900mw hence we'll be exporting to Rwanda? Plus did you know most Kengen power plants are 'throttled' to produce less than 50% of installed capacity in small hours every Fay coz there's nodemand? What we need is to add capacity in tandem with growth, not to generate 5000mw tomorrow As more jobs and opportunities move to the counties i expect more rural homes to light up those 2 or 3 bulbs and if Kenya attracts more manufacturing plants/companies, that 5000MW will be a drop in the ocean. I have a quick question, why would Kenya import power from Uganda and Ethiopia if there's "No demand"? And isn't demand created? Lets think about the future If at best we would project our economic growth rate to be 5-10% over the next 10 years, would we really need to increase power capacity to 250% suddenly by tomorrow? What we need is strike a proper balance, for instance increase by 50-100MW every year if that’s what our growth demands. Then as we do this, we could focus on creating industries, reduce cost of business, improve security, etc so that we can attract more investors and thereby create the actual demand. If growth rate increases down the line, we increase our investment in power to match. If we were to borrow money and build plants to give us 5000MW which we don’t have capacity to consume in the next 20 years, and can’t export in perpetuity since most of the EAC countries in the region are focussing on power and doing the same thing, how are we going to repay the loans? AND..For world bank to fund current EAC power projects, we have to justify where the demand will come from…that’s partly why there are all these projects to interconnect grids between the various countries….otherwise even world bank would not agree to fund Please educate me on how much of the current power we consume is generated from diesel powered generators which I figure are more expensive than hydro or geothermal. Even if you were right, where is the harm in exporting to Rwanda and Uganda? I cringe to think that someone in 2014 AD thinks 5000MW is excess for a country in darkness Combined generating capcity (and thus demand) for UG and Rwanda is about 700MW.If you add TZ, the total for the 3countries is sub 2000MW. So with our 5000MW, we would be able to supply the entire demand in EA (most countries only need import about 10% however) and have 1000MW excess. Is macroeconomics becoming rocket science? so your conclusion is we should sit on our hands now? In actual sense, with the additional 280MW, we have met our quota for the next 2-3 years. Most power projects take 3-5 years from inception to completion, so it is good time to draw a blue print for the next 300MW. But not 3000MW. Or can you tell us why gvt is aiming for 5000MW right now? i.e. not 2500MW, not 3500MW, not 4500MW, not 6500MW, not 7500MW? I would like to see the justification.
|
|
|
Rank: Veteran Joined: 9/21/2011 Posts: 2,032
|
murchr wrote:nakujua wrote:we are talking increased generation and yet only around 30% of kenyans have access to electricity, compared to around 85% with access to a mobile phone. its funny we are so awed by mega projects and fancy economic figures and yet at the same time the government charges the poorest of the souls money to install electricity poles and transformers.
What are you saying? I think he meant something like---You do not borrow to build a tarmarc road in some nondescript rural area hoping people will buy vehicles to use on the road..the economy will shed tears.
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 12/17/2009 Posts: 3,583 Location: Kenya
|
limanika wrote:murchr wrote:nakujua wrote:we are talking increased generation and yet only around 30% of kenyans have access to electricity, compared to around 85% with access to a mobile phone. its funny we are so awed by mega projects and fancy economic figures and yet at the same time the government charges the poorest of the souls money to install electricity poles and transformers.
What are you saying? I think he meant something like---You do not borrow to build a tarmarc road in some nondescript rural area hoping people will buy vehicles to use on the road..the economy will shed tears. Agreed, we borrow our excitement from the west and forget we are at very different levels, and so when the excitement arrives from the developed nations only the small portion that makes up the well to do guys get to feel the same. You can see it within them, the excitement of a young kid from shags on the eve of the promised visit to the big city Its either we come up with a totally new way of doing, and gauging things or we go back to what the west was doing 100 years ago.
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 3/2/2009 Posts: 26,339 Location: Masada
|
murchr wrote:Impunity wrote:Is it true now that geothermal power sources in Kenya has surpassed the Hydro Electric sources? who has these figures? They say our installed capacity is now 1,900 MW.
What is the %age contribution per each?
Geothermal = ? Olkaria I,II,III = 209MW, IV = 280MW. Menengai 60MW expected 400MW; Eburru 2.5MW HEP = ? 743 MW. Thermal/Fossil = ? wind = ? 5.1 MW Solar = ? Others = ? BIOGAS has a huge potential if our sewage system was well utilized BIOMASS Mumias = 35MW sells 26MW to KPLC
Meanwhile Argentina with the same population has installed capacity of 24,000 MW and a population of 40 million just like us. Hydro is still King, but Geothermal will displace it by far Really!? Portfolio: Sold You know you've made it when you get a parking space for your yatcht.
|
|
|
Rank: Elder Joined: 3/29/2011 Posts: 2,242
|
timizo wrote:Even worse is that the jubilee government continue to lie to kenyans that the geothermal was their project and take credit for that. Of course all the planning including the starting of construction was done under the Kibaki administration. On another note, because we have not travelled and seen how others are doing, we tend to think we are the best in africa. May be for the same reason, we have very low expectations from our leaders Who was the Finance Minister then? I am sure it was not Koigi Wamwere? "Things that matter most must never be at the mercy of things that matter least." Goethe
|
|
|
Wazua
»
Club SK
»
Politics
»
Installed Grid Capacity Politrics!!!!!!!!!!!!
Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.
|