Gathige wrote:Siringi wrote:Would appreciate honest reviews from wazuans on the midsize SUV's [Honda, Forrester, Nissan Xtrail and RAV 4]
I have three friends One drives a Honda CRV , Mwingine an Xtrail and the third one a Subaru addict. Now each swears that theirs is the best choice and would never touch any other brands- well except the xtrail guy who moans excessive fuel consumption... My Honda pal has had like three Honda while the Forrester guy started with like two imprezas before graduating to forresters- he's had two... what is is that addicts?
How do wazuans rank these cars (ranked withe the king at no 1)
I have seen Kia Sportage and Ford something i can remember the name
PS test drove a Forrester an I think Subarus are overrated!
@Siringi, I add to the Mid SUV's Toyoya Harrier. It has a smooth ride, very comfortable while driving, a good sound system and the pick-up is very fast. Lakini it is a guzzler
@Gathige in my opinion, Harrier is in a different category from the four listed.
@Siringi about the SUVs, I assume you meant Honda CRV... This my opinion:
1. Honda CRV- most spacious
- most stable (have you ever seen one rolled?)
- consumption competitive with VVTEC technology
- has status/class
- not darling of thieves
- most durable
- resale value very high
- but parts are more expensive
Although, parts are more expensive, they last forever (literally)
2. Forester- moderately spacious
- moderately stable (but misused by people who roll with them once in while, that tells you who are the common owners)
- guzzler especially the turbo
- not sure about the status/class, but it's favourite of the young generation (I don't know why, coud be the sound and power?)
- moderately durable
- cheaper to buy (you cab save upto 1/2 mita i.e. sh500K compared to CRV/RAV4)
- resale value low (you can sell you Forester for months before you get a buyer)
- although the parts are expensive, they last longer than RAV-4 and ofcourse X-Trail
3. RAV-4- very squeezed (try the back seats and wore unto you if you are a tall person)
- moderately stable
- most economical
- moderate status/class
- darling of thieves given that it is a Toyota
- moderately durable
- highly overrated to buy (you can pay over sh500K compared to Forester)
- high resale value (you can sell it in a day due to above point, overated)
- although parts cheaper because of many, many imitations in the market, they last less longer than CRV and Forester
4. Nissan X-trail- moderately spacious
- moderately stable
- slightly guzzler than Honda
- has status/class
- least durable
- resale value very low (you can sell it for years unless throw away price)
- parts are both expensive and last shorter
So make your choice. To me, - take Honda if you have the money and want to have the car until you give it to your grand children
- or Forester if your pocket is a bit squeezed but some for maintenance
- or RAV-4 if you want to sell it quickly at some time in future
- or X-Trail if you want to replace it in less than 10 years as scrap meatal