milken wrote:accelriskconsult wrote:
After talking to a few owners of the Benz (1.8 & 2 litre), I have established that the claim that they are expensive cars to maintain is unfounded.
These cars are serviced after 20k or so kilometres and are rarely involved in accidents as matatus avoid them (safer and less trips to panel beaters). The 1.8 l category is economical in terms of fuel consumption. I see no reason that a middle income earner who wants to own one should not.
I saw a similar claim by the guy comparing VW with a Toyota and I beg to differ.
Servicing will include change of oil, filters, air cleaner and spark plugs.
Which oil (currently available in Kenyan market) can do 20K KMs?
Considering the dust conditions in Kenya, can an air cleaner rated 15K Kms in Europe yield the same mileage locally?
Milken what is the cost of an air cleaner? The only real cost there is the cost of spark plugs and good ones are doing 20 -25k km.
FYI I have talked to 2 people who each own and drive a forester (ya kwenda ushago) and a 1.8 l Benz (for teh jammed roads of Nairobi) and they assure me that the Benz is much cheaper to maintain. I have also talked to someone who owned a legacy but upgraded to the E240 and he says that the difference in fuel consumption is just slightly higher but other costs are not that much. How much does a pair of springs cost the owner of an NZE? Those myths about the cost of lights etc. 6 months ago I lease a Carina and a day later the side mirror+its hub got stolen. I went to Toyota Kenya and was shocked to learn that a genuine replacement would cost me 36k (just one side mirror+hub). Such parts get stolen every other day. The points that are making are simple;
1. Fuel wise, these cars consume the same as any other 1.8l or 2.0 l car (For these categories the cost of fuel is an issue to the owners)
2. Your ancillary parts will not get stolen every now and then so you wont have to replace them
3. The mtaa matatu driver will try as much as possible not to dent your car even when you are on the wrong hence you dont spent a lot of money repairing dents or hiring other cars to replace yours when its in the garage
4. Such cars are not popular with thiefs
5. Except the air and oil filter, you can comfortably drive your car for 20k km before worrying about major service
6. How many times will the police stop a speeding Benz vis a vis a Subaru/Toyota?
One of the paradoxes of life is that the have nots pay more for anything than the haves and it is the same with these cars.
Milken; I have done my research, please do the same and then we can compare notes
I rest my case and please note that I am not talking about the fuel guzzlers in the 3.0 l category